SCA practice case · Video consultation

“My hands shake when I reach for my cup or write — my dad had it too. Is it Parkinson’s?”

Video consultation Adult patient Straightforward New & undifferentiated presentationsLong-term conditions & cancer

The candidate brief

This is what you would read in the 3-minute window before the patient connects. Read it once, note two or three hypotheses and one thing you must not miss, then stop.

Patient
Hugh Brankin · 64 years · male
Setting
Video consultation, with the examination arranged face to face — a tremor, worried about Parkinson’s.
Past history
  • Father had a similar tremor
Medication
  • Repeat list to be reviewed
Allergies
None recorded
Recent notes
Several years of action tremor of both hands; eased by alcohol; no slowness reported.
Reason for contact
“Is it the start of Parkinson’s?”

Practise this case

The full case is in the Hot Seat with the Gold plan. You get a 12-minute timer, a role-player script with facts released only when asked, examiner checkpoints by the three RCGP domains, a model consultation and the guidance behind it.

What this case tests

Show the learning points (spoiler: read after you have practised)
Distinguish ESSENTIAL TREMOR from PARKINSON’S — the core skill in a "shaking hands" presentation. Essential tremor is a postural/action/kinetic tremor that is WORSE ON ACTION and posture (reaching, holding, writing — spidery, eating) and BETTER at rest, typically BILATERAL and fairly SYMMETRICAL, often FAMILIAL, frequently IMPROVED by a small amount of alcohol, sometimes with head ("yes-yes"/"no-no") or voice tremor, and crucially WITHOUT bradykinesia, rigidity or gait disturbance. Parkinson’s tremor, by contrast, is a RESTING "pill-rolling" tremor, typically ASYMMETRIC (one side first), BETTER with action, and accompanied by the parkinsonian features — BRADYKINESIA (slowness, reduced arm swing, micrographia that decrements), RIGIDITY (cogwheel) and gait/postural changes (shuffling, stooped, festination) — so the rest-vs-action distinction and the presence/absence of the parkinsonian triad are the discriminators. Consider other tremors: enhanced PHYSIOLOGICAL (anxiety, caffeine, fatigue), HYPERTHYROIDISM (check TFTs), DRUGS (salbutamol, lithium, SSRIs, valproate — review), excess alcohol/withdrawal, cerebellar INTENTION tremor (worse approaching a target, with cerebellar signs) and dystonic tremor. Examine the tremor at rest, on posture (arms outstretched) and on action (finger-nose, cup, writing/spiral), and assess for bradykinesia, rigidity, gait and cerebellar signs, which underpins the diagnosis and reassurance. Manage essential tremor by reassuring when mild (directly addressing the Parkinson’s fear), and offering PROPRANOLOL (licensed for essential tremor; check for asthma, bradycardia/heart block and heart failure first) or primidone when functionally impairing or socially distressing (BNF; clinical practice rather than a guideline recommendation), while reducing caffeine, reviewing aggravating drugs and treating thyroid abnormality; refer to neurology for diagnostic uncertainty, atypical/asymmetric features, suspected parkinsonism (NICE NG71: quickly and untreated) or cerebellar signs, or refractory tremor. The hidden agenda is fear of Parkinson’s plus embarrassment/functional impact; make the action-vs-rest distinction, reassure appropriately while screening properly, address the impact and offer treatment, and refer if uncertain.

The guidance behind it

Similar SCA cases

Browse all 359 cases by experience group →

gpreasoning.uk is not affiliated with or endorsed by the RCGP. Our cases are original teaching material written for practice; none is an exam recall. For anything official about the SCA, check the RCGP SCA pages.